Catching Knives
Catching falling knives (buying distressed assets) is tricky business, even the most seasoned investors get cut badly. The task seems relatively easy, yet perfect execution is a rarity. The challenge of buying on the low revolves around having almost perfect information. That is highly elusive, sometimes illegal, and in a multi-variable world with intense competition vying for any edge, almost impossible.
Investors hoping to scoop up additional alpha should leave the knife catching to the circus. Outfits like Ringling Bros perfected "the spinning wheel of death" so retail investors do not have to literally reinvent the wheel!
Rather, retail investors should consider playing to THEIR advantages over "professional money" like hedge funds, family offices, and AI-trading algo bots. Consider instead a boring, dollar-cost-averaging approach to building a portfolio over a LIFETIME with incremental purchases occurring multiple times a month.
By implementation of a dollar-cost-averaging approach, investors are constantly buying equites (and bonds) over a period of time that will have both highs and lows, and by default, greater position size will be purchased during selloffs and lower position sizes at the highs.
These DCA plans are relatively easy to set-up, and now virtually "free" with zero commissions. The rub of course, is always portfolio allocation...what exactly to buy? Portfolio allocation is critical to success.
Trepidation occurs when a portfolio has been built over some time and perhaps is no longer being built (ie inbound flows have stopped) and the portfolio is now in a "depletion phase," primarily used to pay for cost of living expenses.
The larger and older a portfolio gets, the more it is subject to short-term market forces, and also the temptation to make significant rash moves...this is exactly why this blog is a proponent of building a portfolio like a farm.
Investors should have multiple "crops" ie baskets of equities whose cash flow can and should weather a financial storm(s). Ultimately most investing boils down to cash flow, so how are you building your cash flow? Do you have a repeatable process in place? Is your cash flow compounding? What companies are consistently raising their dividends? What are the best moats? What is the caliber of leadership in place? Can your portfolio take advantage of a higher Vix?
As previously mentioned, all these factors must be weighed because portfolio allocation is critical to success. This is why putting an emphasis on timing rather than process is dangerous; it skews the thought process from investing to gambling, and there is a significant difference between the two. Investors have odds in their favor, gamblers do not.
Catching knives is tricky business. For investors sitting on ready cash though it is deliciously tempting to go "all-in" after the market stumbles, and even more appealing after a tumble. Indeed, many great fortunes have been made in this manner (ie Rothschild family wealth was built off of perfect information.) If so compelled, have a playbook ready; know what assets you want to buy, at what price, and with what margin of safety this impacts your total portfolio.


